Same citizenship but not same rights…

As I once said on one of my tweets: I believe that American democracy is designed to give its people the right to choose their leaders and their form of government. It “seems” to me that this right has somehow been denied to the US citizens who live in Puerto Rico.

Tweeter account: luisriddle

Tweeter account: luisriddle

If Puerto Ricans and mainlanders both hold the same citizenship, why not give them the same rights?

Following the provisions of the Foraker Act, changes were made on the way business was to be done on the island. On the economic side, the United States took this opportunity to implement taxation of all islanders. A fifteen percent tax was levied on all articles entering Puerto Rico from the United States and vice-versa. Along with a tax increase, the United States instituted, “the coastwise shipping laws, prohibiting less expensive foreign carriers from shipping cargo between Puerto Rico and the United States”. Essentially, the United States mandated that Puerto Rican commerce was to be carried out on American ships, and failing to do so often led to severe economic consequences. Political leaders from both the United States and Puerto Rico were appalled that such a law was permitted to pass through Congress. In many ways the US Congress contradicted some of the fundamental philosophies of its Constitution. As it was stated by their founding Fathers, in response to the British taxation of the thirteen colonies, “taxation without representations is a crime that will not be tolerated by the people of this island”.

I found this contradiction while leafing through the thesis of Nils ZetterstrandThe Globalization of the pharmaceutical industry in Puerto Rico”, 2001.

This entry was posted in Books, Scholar and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Same citizenship but not same rights…

  1. Luis Riddle says:

    “The [American] Ideal is this you see, that every people in the wold should have self-gouvernment and equal rights. This means, when reduced from windy oratory to common-sense, that they consider these Malay half-breeds to be capable … of understanding the motives, and profiting by the institutions which it has taken the highest white races two or three thousand years to evolve … When I come to think of it, America with this funny little possession of hers is like a mother with her fisrt child, who … tries to bring it up on some fad of her own because it is so much more preciuous and more wonderful than any other child any one else ever had”.

    Mrs. Campbell Dauncey, an Englishwoman in the Philippines.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s